A community interest company, or CIC, is a limited company built for social enterprise: it trades like a business, but its profits and assets are locked in for the benefit of the community. We see more of them every year in Belfast and across Northern Ireland, from youth projects and community cafés to arts groups and training providers.
We have already written about what a CIC has to file each year. This guide is the step before that: how to set one up, and the choices that are hard to undo afterwards.
Is a CIC the right structure?
A CIC is the right fit when you want to earn income by trading, keep the legal protection of a limited company, and give the public and your funders confidence that the money stays in the community. It is not a charity, and it does not have a charity’s tax or regulatory status. Charities in Northern Ireland have their own regulator and their own rules, and our guide to charity accounting in Northern Ireland covers that route.
Be honest with yourself about one thing: a CIC is hard to leave. Once a company is a CIC it cannot become an ordinary company. It can convert to a charity, or it can be dissolved, but it cannot simply drop the CIC rules. That is the point of the structure, and it is worth being sure before you start.
The community interest test
To be approved, you have to pass the community interest test. In the regulator’s words, it asks whether “a reasonable person might consider that the CIC’s activities are or will be carried on for the benefit of the community”.
Two things will make you fail it. The first is political activity: a political party, a political campaigning organisation, or a subsidiary of either cannot be a CIC. The second is a purpose that benefits only a closed group, such as the members of one body or the employees of one employer, rather than the wider community.
Your community interest statement is where you set out who benefits and how. Write it plainly and concretely. The regulator decides applications by examining it, so it is worth taking time over.
The asset lock
Every CIC has a compulsory asset lock, and it cannot be removed. Assets cannot be handed to individuals such as directors, members or shareholders. Anything that leaves the CIC has to go at full market value, or to a named asset-locked body such as another CIC or a charity, or be used for the benefit of the community.
It is a core part of what a CIC is, so it is not something to try to negotiate around.
Shares or guarantee?
A CIC must be either a company limited by guarantee or a company limited by shares. You cannot switch between the two later, so this is a decision to take with some care.
- Limited by guarantee: members promise to cover the company’s debts up to a small set sum, usually a nominal £1. Dividends are a feature of share companies, not guarantee ones. The regulator’s guidance notes that funders tend to look more favourably on guarantee companies, which matters if you plan to rely on grants.
- Limited by shares: shareholders can be paid dividends, subject to the dividend cap. The cap is 35% of the CIC’s profits in aggregate, with the remaining 65% reinvested or used for the community. Performance-related interest on money you borrow is capped at 20%.
If you are unsure, ask what you actually want to do with the surplus. If the honest answer is “put it back into the project”, guarantee is usually simpler. If you need to attract investors who expect a return, shares gives you room, within the cap.
The practical steps
- Write the community interest statement. Who does the CIC serve, and what will it do for them?
- Decide your structure. Shares or guarantee, who the directors are, and how decisions will be taken.
- Prepare the constitution. The CIC Regulator publishes model constitutions you can start from. Whatever you use must contain the asset lock.
- Apply. You register through Companies House, online or by post. An online application is sent to the CIC Regulator automatically for approval. Companies House and the Regulator are separate bodies: one registers the company, the other decides whether it can be a CIC.
- Set up the basics. Open a business bank account, agree who signs, and make sure each director has verified their identity with Companies House. Our guide to director ID verification in NI explains what that involves.
After you are registered
A CIC has more annual paperwork than an ordinary limited company. Alongside statutory accounts, a confirmation statement and a Company Tax Return, you file a CIC34 community interest company report each year, which goes on the public record. It is worth building that into your calendar from day one. Our article on CIC accounts in Northern Ireland sets out the full annual set, the deadlines and the common mistakes.
You also need to keep your books in a way that supports the report: directors’ pay, anything transferred out of the CIC, and what you have done for the community should all be easy to find.
Common mistakes
- Choosing the wrong share structure and finding out later that it does not suit your funders.
- A thin community interest statement that does not say clearly who benefits.
- Assuming a CIC is a charity. It is a company, with company filings and company obligations.
- Leaving directors’ identity verification until the first deadline.
- Not planning for the CIC34 until the accounts are already due.
How Arro Group can help
We work with community and not-for-profit organisations across Belfast and Northern Ireland, and many of our clients are directors who give their time alongside a day job. Arro Group forms CICs for clients. We can help you think through the structure before you apply, handle the Companies House registration, and then look after your annual accounts and prepare and file your CIC34 each year. Have a look at our not-for-profit sector page, or get in touch for a friendly first conversation.